[MCAT Success Story] — How Kayla Scored 131 In Psych/Soc on the MCAT (MCAT Case Study)

March 26, 2024

minute read

This top scorer MCAT case study is jam packed with a lot of valuable information, so we highly suggest you read it all the way through to the end.

You'll very likely pick up on one or two golden nuggets of information that will help you in your MCAT prep.

With that said, in this article we'd like to introduce you to Kayla S., a 511 scorer...


With a 131 in Psychology/Sociology, we made sure we found out how Kayla studied for that section, which we'll reveal later in this article.

Additionally Kayla plans to retake the MCAT, which we'll also talk more about later in this article. So lots of good stuff coming up but first...

We asked Kayla to give us some insight into her MCAT journey, including how she prepped and what her schedule was like...

"Immediately after school ended for the summer I really dove into my MCAT studying.

I made a schedule to work around my other obligations and stuck to it. I was lucky enough to have a scribe job and volunteer research position that allowed me to take ~2.5 weeks completely off prior to my test.

I studied greatly for about 2 weeks with some work and research on the side, but dedicated those last 2.5 weeks before my test to complete and utter MCAT studying.

I struggled to focus during my 12 hour study days, but would set myself a timer for ~1-1.5 hours and make myself focus solely on that for the allotted time before I took a break or ate a snack."

It's common to see 510+ scorers create and stick to an MCAT study schedule that works for them, dedicating the last 2-4 weeks to strictly MCAT studying, and managing energy through the use of breaks...

Looks like she did everything the "top scorer way" here, which isn't surprising since she did download and go through the Top Scorer MCAT Strategy Guide...

Besides those insights, we asked Kayla what other strategies in the guide she found valuable in helping her achieve the MCAT score that she got...

"I came across the MCAT strategy guide and was SO happy that I did. It hit on all the questions I had and all the strategies that I needed to implement in my studying.

Most of all, it made me really focus on the PROCESS - studying for the MCAT is not about memorizing techniques, methods, terminology. It is about connecting ideas and being able to apply them.

I spent a lot of my spring college semester taking notes on my
MCAT prep books, but those only touch on the specifics and from all my studying, I really started to realize that someone could truly take the test with only basic science information and still do well as long as you know how to comprehend, analyze, make predictions, and interpret scientific readings.This is exactly what the strategy guide helped emphasize, which was something that I had never quite grasped, since all other prep companies sell you on needing to memorizing all the specifics.

Something I also found EXTREMELY helpful were the
"mental health" tips. Having been a competitive athlete, I can honestly say that the MCAT is utterly and truly a marathon.

Just with athletics, your mind is everything. I started meditating for ~10 mins each morning before going off to my studies, and although I never really noticed pronounced changes in my scores, I did notice an overall improvement in my focus and general being content. Meditating helped me see the silver linings in each day of studies."

Very well articulated. The key is to remember:

  • Firstly, studying for the MCAT is about the process - connecting ideas and being able to apply them. So many premeds are just memorizing and using 'average' ways of studying that get 'average' results, which won't cut it if you want an easy acceptance to med-school. It's critical that you get a good grasp on how to conquer the process, if you want to conquer the MCAT.
  • Secondly, if you're not meditating, start ASAP. It is one of the most powerful MCAT study hacks top scorers commonly use.
  • Lastly, doing well on the MCAT is all about knowing HOW to take the MCAT. It's not like any other exam. Like Kayla said, you need to "know how to comprehend, analyze, make predictions, and interpret scientific readings." Learn these key methods as soon as possible. The sooner you do it, the easier the MCAT becomes. 

Next, what was Kayla's approach for getting a 131 on P/S? Here's how she said she did it...

"Out of all the sections, I usually go the absolute slowest for P/S, despite it being somewhat of an easier section for me. I noticed that when I went quickly through, telling myself I could recheck weird questions later, I always made more smaller mistakes that I wouldn't think to check back on. Then I began to treat each question as if it was the last time I would be seeing it - take my time, make my best judgement, and move on.

Of course, if there is a question that is wordy, confusing, or vague, I mark it and go back in hopes that taking a break from it and coming back will allow me to see something that I missed before.

So it's really a balance - going slow and making each answer "final", but also knowing when a question could use a second look later on from a fresh perspective.

In my opinion, I also feel like P/S section is not trying to trick you like many of the other sections seem to, so I try not to overthink them. Usually the answers end up being the simplest (Law of Pragmanz?!) And of course, pure memorization of terms helps haha. Looking up any terms I would come across and noting them either in Anki cards, quizlet, etc."

Great points here. We'd just like to take this moment to remind you that there's no harm in trying a top scorer's strategy. Chances are it's going to work and help improve your score but if it doesn't after several attempts, don't force yourself to stick to it.

Everyone is different and at the end of the day, one of the best MCAT strategies is to know yourself.

Lastly, as we mentioned earlier, Kayla is retaking the MCAT. As you may have guessed, it's due to her CARS score. So we asked her to share her CARS experience, her biggest challenge, and how she plans on improving her score...

"In all honesty, I'm not exactly sure what happened there. My lowest CARS score on any AAMC practice test was a 126 and my highest a 128, so my 123 was substantially lower than I would have ever expected. That being said, out of all the sections, CARS was probably the most different on my real test than any of the practices - much longer, but truthfully I didn't think the passages were very difficult.

I guess I was expecting vague philosophy or convoluted literature passages, but what I saw instead were just really long, casual passages (narratives really) with more convoluted questions. Because of that, I'm thinking I may have gotten so caught up in understanding the passage (despite it not being as difficult as expected), and then not leaving myself enough time for the questions.

I messed my timing up for sure - ended up having to guess on most of last passage, which had never happened to me before, though I didn't think that would hurt me as much as it did."

If someone is getting decent scores on AAMC practice tests and on the real they got a much lower score than normal, it’s usually a sign of either unexpectedly weird or hard questions on test day, which happens rarely OR it’s a sign of nerves getting in the way on test day, and screwing up timing by causing them to read/analyze/overthink more than they should, etc. 

From the sounds of it, it seems like Kayla may have just gotten an ‘off’ CARS section that day - probably still manageable enough for her to do well on it, but because it wasn’t something she was used to or expected, it might have thrown her off, triggering some worry so she spent more time reading than she needed to, and her overall timing suffered as a result, which lowered her score even further.

Here are some of the improvements Kayla has in mind that she'd like to make...

"I did not focus so much on identifying question/answer types or the difficulty of the passages, so that would be something I would like to give more attention to this next time around. I also want to get in the habit of being more comfortable reading through convoluted, vague, boring passages even more so than I was before. Also, biggest improvement that will need to be made is my timing."

We cover the 130+ CARS scorer methodology for each one of those areas, in the CARS Mastery Course.

If you're struggling with CARS or any section of the MCAT, we highly recommend you don't wait until you get your scores back to realize what steps you should have taken and what areas you should have improved on...

Having to retake the MCAT is a huge, painful burden on your time, your application, your money, your emotions, your self-esteem, your mental strength... even your relationships.

Study in the smartest way possible now, so you don't have any regrets later, by copying the same systems many 515+ scorers have used when they studied for the MCAT...

So you can make sure, this is the last time you write the MCAT.

Even if you think you're studying properly and your MCAT prep can't get any better, it doesn't hurt to be absolutely sure.

At the very least, you'll watch the lessons and see that 515+ scorers are studying exactly how you're currently studying, and that will give you a big boost in your confidence and self esteem...

Where instead of thinking you're going to do well on the MCAT, you'll know...

You got this,

The MedLife Mastery Team
Your "MCAT Success" Mentors

Additional Reading -- MCAT Success Stories:

Your MCAT Success Mentors

About the Author

We're a team of future doctors passionate about giving back and mentoring other future doctors! All mentors on the team are top MCAT scorers and we all are committed to seeing you succeed in achieving your physician dreams ???? To help you achieve your goal MCAT score, we take turns hosting these Live MCAT Courses and are also available for 1:1 private tutoring!

70+ MCAT Strategy Video Lessons + Notes - Free!

The Free Top Scorer MCAT Strategy Video Course

Learn from multiple 515+ scorers on how to:

  • Master MCAT content quickly and for the long-term
  • Breakdown MCAT questions and identify correct answers
  • Plan your MCAT prep schedule to ensure you stay committed
  • Take and review practice exams in the most strategic way
  • Cultivate the right MCAT success mindset
  • Know how to study as a retaker to ensure this is the last MCAT prep
  • And much more!

Trusted by 2,800+ students since 2019

200+ 5  ⭐️ reviews on TrustPilot

Success message!
Warning message!
Error message!